Product Guides
Steel vs Plastic Water Tanks: Which Is Right for a Commercial Site?

A practical comparison of steel and plastic water tanks for commercial, industrial and fire water storage, and how to choose between them.
For small volumes and quick installs, plastic (polyethylene) tanks are usually the cheaper and simpler choice. For commercial, industrial and fire water storage, where volumes run into tens or hundreds of kilolitres, steel tanks are usually the better fit because one engineered tank can replace many plastic units, can be split into compartments and is built for a long service life.
Most buyers in South Africa know plastic tanks well, because they are common on homes and small businesses. When a site needs bulk storage, the comparison changes. This guide sets out the differences that matter on a commercial project so you can specify with confidence.
Key takeaways
- Plastic tanks suit small volumes, light foundations and fast installation.
- Steel tanks suit bulk volumes, fire water storage, compartments and long service life.
- Above about the size of a few large plastic tanks, the number of units, connections and the footprint start to count against plastic.
- Summer heat and sun exposure are a bigger long-term factor for plastic tanks than for coated steel.
- Compare the full installed cost for the same effective capacity, not just the price per tank.
How each tank type is made
Plastic water tanks
Plastic water tanks are moulded from polyethylene as single pieces. In South Africa they are made to SANS 1731 for polyethylene storage tanks. They are light, quick to place and need no assembly on site. Because they are moulded in one piece, each tank is limited to the sizes a mould can produce, so larger volumes need several tanks connected together.
Steel water tanks
Steel water tanks are engineered structures built from steel panels. Videx makes two main types, both designed to SANS 10329:
- Sectional steel tanks: bolted, hot-dip galvanised panels (SANS 121) assembled on site into square or rectangular tanks, from small modular units up to multi-megalitre reservoirs.
- Cylindrical steel tanks: a round Aluzinc AZ150 coated shell with a food-grade PVC liner that holds the water.
Because steel tanks are built from panels, their capacity is set by design, not by a mould.
Steel vs plastic: side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Plastic (polyethylene) tank | Steel tank |
|---|---|---|
| Typical volume | Single tanks in the thousands of litres; larger volumes need multiple tanks | Small modular tanks up to multi-megalitre reservoirs in one structure |
| Installation | Delivered whole, placed on a level base | Delivered as panels and erected on site by a trained team |
| Footprint for large volumes | Several tanks plus space between them | One tank, sized and shaped to the site |
| Compartments | One compartment per tank | Internal partition walls possible in sectional tanks |
| Fire water storage | Check with your fire engineer and insurer first | Videx steel tanks are ASIB-listed for sprinkler and hydrant reserves |
| Sun and heat exposure | Material ages with UV and heat over time | Coated steel shell with liner or galvanised panels |
| Repairs | Damaged tanks are usually replaced | Panels, sealant and liners can be repaired or replaced |
| Upfront cost | Lower for small volumes | Usually more economical as volume increases |
When plastic tanks make sense
- The volume is small. A home, a small shop or a site office needing a few thousand litres is well served by plastic.
- The site needs water storage quickly. Plastic tanks can be delivered and connected in a day.
- The tank may move. Plastic tanks are easy to relocate on temporary sites.
- Foundations are limited. A small plastic tank needs a solid, level base but not an engineered foundation.
When steel tanks make sense
Bulk storage
When a site needs tens or hundreds of kilolitres, the number of plastic tanks needed grows quickly, along with the connecting pipework, valves and footprint. One steel tank stores the same volume with one inlet, one outlet and one overflow. At East Rand Mall, for example, a single cylindrical Aluzinc steel tank provides 103.17 kL of effective storage in a compact circular footprint.
Fire water storage
Sprinkler and hydrant systems need a dedicated, reliable water reserve that meets the fire design and insurer requirements. Videx steel fire water tanks are ASIB-listed and supplied with the documentation needed for certification. Projects such as Leroy Merlin Cornubia, with two 315.59 kL tanks, show the scale involved. Read more on our fire protection tanks page.
Compartments and maintenance
A sectional steel tank can be split with an internal wall, so one side keeps supplying the site while the other is drained for cleaning or inspection. This is useful for any site that cannot afford to be without water.
Long service life
Steel tanks are built for a long service life, and their parts can be maintained. On a sectional tank, panels, bolts and sealant can be inspected and replaced. On a round tank, the liner can be replaced without replacing the steel shell.
Tight or awkward sites
Sectional tanks can be configured as long rectangles to fit narrow service yards, where several round plastic tanks would waste space.
Summer heat, sun and tank lifespan
South African summers are long and hot, and most tanks stand in full sun. Polyethylene tanks are made with UV stabilisers, but heat and sunlight still age the material over time. Steel tanks rely on their coatings (hot-dip galvanising or Aluzinc) and, for round tanks, an internal liner. For any tank type, stored water in a hot, sunny location benefits from a sealed roof, regular cleaning and a sensible turnover so water does not stand for long periods.
Comparing cost properly
Price per tank is a misleading comparison for bulk storage. To compare fairly, price both options on the same effective capacity and include:
- The number of tanks needed and the connecting pipework, valves and manifolds
- Foundations or bases for each tank
- Installation time and labour
- Space used on site, especially where land is valuable
- Expected service life and maintenance
- Requirements for fire water storage, if applicable
At small volumes plastic usually wins on upfront cost. As volume grows, a single steel tank often becomes the more economical and practical choice.
Questions to ask before you choose
- What effective capacity does the site need now, and in five years?
- Is any of the storage for fire protection?
- How much space is available, including access for maintenance?
- Does the site need to keep water available while a tank is cleaned?
- What is the expected life of the installation?
- What will the foundation need to carry?
For help with the first question, read our guide on how to size a water storage tank. If you have already chosen steel, our comparison of sectional vs round steel water tanks explains which steel tank suits your site.
Frequently asked questions
Are steel water tanks safe for drinking water?
Yes, when they are specified for potable use. In Videx round steel tanks the water is held in a food-grade PVC liner, and sectional tanks use hot-dip galvanised panels. Your engineer will confirm the right specification for the water quality required.
Do steel tanks rust?
Steel tanks are protected by their coatings. Videx sectional tanks are hot-dip galvanised to SANS 121, and round tanks use Aluzinc AZ150 coated steel with an internal liner. Regular inspection and maintenance keep that protection working.
Can I connect several plastic tanks instead of buying one steel tank?
You can, and it is common for small volumes. For large volumes, the extra pipework, connections, footprint and maintenance points add up, and fire water storage has its own design and approval requirements, so check with your fire engineer and insurer.
Which is cheaper, steel or plastic?
Plastic is usually cheaper for small volumes. For bulk storage, compare both options on the same effective capacity, including foundations, pipework, installation and lifespan.
This article provides general guidance only. The right tank for your project depends on capacity, site conditions, water use and design requirements, which should be confirmed by a qualified engineer.
About this article
Written by the engineering team at Videx Storage Tanks, a South African manufacturer of sectional and cylindrical steel water storage tanks based in Wadeville, Gauteng, with a branch in Bellville, Cape Town. Videx has more than 40 years of experience and more than 500 completed projects, and is ISO 9001:2015 certified.
Weighing up tank options for a commercial site? Speak to a Videx engineer for advice on capacity, layout and specification.
